Posts

Showing posts from October, 2009

Do Balanced Budgets Cause Depressions? (Part 2)

Image
My prior post suggested that the initial events that lead to financial crises are more likely wars, not the periods of paying down the resultant debt. The following graph shows the federal debt held by the public during major wars since 1790: The actual numbers and sources can be found at this link . The graph shows the federal debt as a percentage of GDP, as opposed to my prior post which deals with the current dollar amounts. The debt as a percentage of GDP gives a better measure of our ability to service the debt since the government receipts used to pay the interest have remained around 18 percent of GDP for the past 50-plus years (see the first graph at this link ). In any event, the graph shows that there was a tremendous growth in the debt during the Civil War, World War I, and World War II. The growth in debt was much more rapid than any paydown in debt after the war. The growth in debt during the Mexican-American War and the War of 1812 was much more modest but the paydo...

Do Balanced Budgets Cause Depressions?

According to this link , Frederick C. Thayer, a professor of Public Administration at George Washington University, wrote an article titled "Do Balanced Budgets Cause Depressions?" for The Washington Spectator on January 1, 1996. Following is an excerpt: Even though the sequence that begins with budget-balancing and ends with depression has been common in American history, the question of a linkage has been ignored. The following paragraphs include all the basic data: 1817-21: In a period of five consecutive years, the national debt was reduced by 29 percent, to $90 million. The first acknowledged major depression began in 1819. 1823-36: In a period of 14 consecutive years, the national debt was reduced by 99.7 percent, to $38,000, a virtual wipeout. This didn’t help either. A major depression began in 1837. 1852-57: In a period of six consecutive years, the national debt was reduced by 59 percent, to $28.7 million. A major depression began in 1857. 1867-73: In a period of s...